Ruling Comes Days After Families of Sandy Hook School Mass Shooting Victims Reach $73 Million Settlement with Gun Manufacturer
SANTA FE, Texas — Today, the Texas Supreme Court ruled that Luckygunner.com, an online ammunition seller, must face a lawsuit brought on behalf of the victims of the 2018 mass shooting at Sante Fe High School, rejecting the company’s bid to dismiss the suit and allowing the case to move forward. In its failed attempt to have the Texas Supreme Court overturn lower court rulings and dismiss the case, Luckygunner.com argued that the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act, or PLCAA, provided them with immunity. However, the Plaintiffs successfully argued that PLCAA does not protect their illegal conduct.
“Today’s ruling from the Texas Supreme Court is the latest indication that PLCAA does not immunize members of the gun industry from lawsuits when they are alleged to have engaged in illegal conduct – like selling ammunition to minors,” said Alla Lefkowitz, Director of Affirmative Litigation at Everytown Law and co-counsel for Abdul Aziz and Farah Naz, whose daughter Sabika Aziz Sheikh was killed in the shooting. “We’re honored to continue our work on Sabika’s family’s behalf to hold reckless actors in the gun industry accountable for the devastation caused by their irresponsible and illegal practices.”
This decision comes on the heels of a $73 million settlement reached on Tuesday in litigation arising out of the 2012 mass shooting at Sandy Hook School in Newtown, Connecticut. That settlement came after a 2019 Supreme Court of Connecticut ruling that PLCAA does not immunize the gun industry against lawsuits which claim that they violated state consumer protection laws.
The Texas lawsuit alleges that the 17-year-old Santa Fe High School shooter bought handgun and shotgun ammunition on Luckygunner.com, which accepted payment in prepaid American Express gift cards and never verified his age, before he killed 10 people and wounded 13 others in the shooting.
The claims against Luckygunner.com and its owners were filed in March 2020 by the families of seven children and a teacher murdered at Santa Fe High School, along with two surviving students and one surviving teacher injured in the shooting. They are part of an ongoing civil suit against the shooter and his parents. Luckygunner argued that the case against it should be dismissed because of the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act, a federal law which offers special protection to the gun industry, but the plaintiffs successfully argued that Luckygunner was not entitled to PLCAA’s protection.
Everytown Law, the litigation arm of Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund, and the law firms of Martinez & McGuire PLLC and the Law Offices of Martin J. Siegel represent the family of Sabika Aziz Sheikh, one of the students killed in the shooting. Click here to read more about Sabika in the Texas Monthly cover story Faith, Friendship and Tragedy at Santa Fe High.
The plaintiffs allege negligence, negligence per se, conspiracy and violations of the federal firearms laws against Luckygunner.com and its owners, including that:
- In March of 2018 — just weeks after the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School — the Santa Fe High School shooter ordered 50 rounds of handgun ammunition in violation of federal law and 140 rounds of shotgun ammunition from the website Luckygunner.com.
- To complete his order, the 17-year-old did not have to show any ID or otherwise submit proof of his age, create a Luckygunner account or set up a secure two-step authorization. He did not even need to show that he was old enough to possess a validly issued credit card, as he was able to use prepaid American Express gift cards to make his purchases. It is not even clear that he was required to check a terms and conditions box agreeing, among other things, that he was not under 21.
- The shooter was apparently so confident Luckygunner wouldn’t check his age that he felt comfortable using his own name and address to illegally purchase the ammunition.
- In less than two minutes, Luckygunner approved his order, which was mailed to the shooter’s home two days later.
About Everytown Law
Everytown Law, the litigation arm of Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund, is the largest team of litigators in the U.S. working full-time on advancing gun violence prevention in the courts. Everytown Law fights for the right of every individual to live free from gun violence, including challenging dangerous gun laws, defending gun safety laws against Second Amendment and preemption challenges, and representing survivors of gun violence seeking accountability and reform from the gun industry. Learn more about Everytown Law at www.everytownlaw.org.
Everytown Law regularly posts commentary and analysis on firearms litigation issues and developments at https://medium.com/everytown-
