Highlights
-
Credit card surcharges are legal in most states, but rules vary widely.
-
Strict disclosure rules apply: customers must see the fee before paying.
-
Debit and prepaid cards cannot be surcharged under federal law.
-
Maximum surcharge is 3%–4%, depending on card network guidelines.
-
State bans are disappearing, but compliance remains a moving target.
Across industries, businesses are relying more than ever on credit card payments. Customers expect fast, secure, digital transactions, and merchants who don’t accept cards risk losing sales. But as credit card usage grows, so do the processing fees that businesses must absorb.
To offset those costs, many businesses consider adding credit card surcharges—fees passed on to customers who choose to pay with a credit card. While this practice can help protect margins, it’s also heavily regulated. The rules around surcharging are complex, with federal restrictions, state-level differences, and strict card network requirements.
Understanding surcharge compliance is crucial for any business that accepts credit cards.
What Are Credit Card Surcharges?
A surcharge is an extra fee added to a customer’s bill if they pay with a credit card. Businesses use it to recover merchant processing fees, which generally range from 2% to 4%.
Example: On a $100 sale, a 3% surcharge adds $3, helping the business avoid eating that cost.
While simple in concept, surcharges are closely monitored. Missteps can lead to fines, legal liability, or reputational damage.
Federal Rules on Surcharges
At the national level, federal law and card network rules set clear boundaries:
-
Debit & Prepaid Cards Cannot Be Surcharged
Surcharges are only permitted on credit card transactions. Even if a debit card is run as “credit,” it cannot be surcharged.
-
Maximum Surcharge Allowed
Visa, Mastercard, and Discover generally cap surcharges at 3%, while American Express may allow up to 4%. The surcharge can never exceed the business’s actual processing cost.
-
Disclosure Requirements
Surcharges must be disclosed both before the customer pays (signage in-store, notices online) and on the receipt. Hidden fees are strictly prohibited.
State Laws on Surcharging
Historically, some states banned credit card surcharges outright. New York, California, Texas, and others once prohibited the practice. But legal challenges have overturned many of these bans.
-
Legal in Most States – Today, more than 40 states allow surcharging, provided businesses comply with disclosure and fee limits.
-
Restrictions Remain in Some Areas – A few states still prohibit or restrict surcharges. Businesses must check their local rules.
-
Penalties for Violations – Noncompliance can lead to state fines, voided contracts, and customer lawsuits.
The result is a patchwork landscape: what’s legal in one state may still be restricted in another.
Why Businesses Consider Surcharging
Processing fees eat directly into margins—especially for industries with high transaction volumes or thin profit margins.
For example, a retail store doing $50,000 a month in credit card sales might pay $1,500 or more in fees. Over a year, that adds up to nearly $20,000. By shifting the cost to customers who choose to pay with credit cards, businesses preserve revenue.
However, surcharging is not without risk. Customers may perceive it as unfair or choose competitors that don’t surcharge. For this reason, many businesses:
-
Offer cash or debit discounts
-
Highlight no-fee payment methods like ACH or checks
-
Apply surcharges selectively, such as only on large purchases
How to Stay Compliant
To avoid penalties and customer backlash, businesses must follow strict compliance practices:
-
Provide Clear Notice – Post signage at points of sale and disclose fees on online checkout pages.
-
Itemize on Receipts – The surcharge must appear as a separate line item.
-
Cap the Fee – Never exceed the lower of your actual processing cost or the card network’s maximum.
-
Exclude Debit Cards – Even when run as credit, debit cards cannot be surcharged.
Surcharges vs. Convenience Fees
Businesses often confuse surcharges with convenience fees. The two are different:
- Surcharge: A percentage fee applied to credit card transactions (heavily regulated).
- Convenience Fee: A flat fee charged for using a non-standard payment channel (e.g., paying online instead of mailing a check).
- Mixing up these terms can cause compliance issues, so businesses must carefully distinguish between them.
Recent Legal Shifts
Over the past decade, litigation has reshaped the surcharge landscape:
- Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman (2017) – The U.S. Supreme Court struck down New York’s anti-surcharge law on free speech grounds, leading to similar challenges in other states.
- Repeals & Reforms – States including California, Florida, and Texas have since modified or repealed their bans, making surcharges widely permissible.
That said, state laws continue to evolve, and businesses must monitor developments to remain compliant.
Key Takeaways for Businesses
-
Verify State Rules – Always confirm your state’s stance before implementing surcharges.
-
Follow Network Rules – Visa, Mastercard, Amex, and Discover each have reporting and compliance requirements.
-
Be Transparent With Customers – Clear communication prevents disputes and builds trust.
-
Offer Alternatives – Encourage cash, debit, or ACH payments to avoid customer frustration.
-
Stay Informed – Laws are shifting; compliance strategies must evolve as rules change.
Why This Story Matters
Surcharging may seem like a simple way to reduce costs, but for businesses, it carries real legal and reputational risks. Mishandling surcharges can lead to state penalties, customer backlash, or even card network penalties.
At the same time, with profit margins shrinking and digital payments increasing, surcharging offers a legitimate way to protect revenue. Businesses that apply these rules carefully—following both the letter of the law and the expectations of their customers—can benefit from cost savings while maintaining trust.
In today’s competitive environment, compliance is not optional; it’s part of smart, sustainable business practice.
